For years, The Five has been the network’s crown jewel, drawing millions of viewers with its lively debates, sharp commentary, and sometimes unpredictable chemistry. Jessica Tarlov, the show’s liberal voice, had become a familiar presence, frequently clashing with her conservative counterparts and providing the kind of fiery exchanges that viewers tuned in for. Her departure marks the end of an era—and the beginning of another.
Sandra Smith is no stranger to Fox News audiences. As a seasoned anchor with years of experience on shows like America’s Newsroom and Outnumbered, she’s known for her incisive analysis, quick wit, and ability to keep discussions focused even in the heat of disagreement. But her move to The Five is a bold one, signaling not just a change in personnel but potentially a whole new direction for the program.
The announcement was made in classic Fox News fashion—live, unscripted, and utterly dramatic. As the cameras rolled, Greg Gutfeld, one of the show’s most outspoken personalities, welcomed Smith to the table. The chemistry between Smith and Gutfeld was immediately apparent, with both exchanging playful banter and sharp insights. It didn’t take long for viewers to realize that this new pairing could be something special.
Social media reaction was swift and passionate. Fans of Jessica Tarlov expressed shock and disappointment, with many praising her for bringing a much-needed progressive perspective to the show. “Jessica was the only reason I watched The Five,” tweeted one viewer. “She challenged the panel and kept things honest.” Others, however, welcomed Sandra Smith’s arrival, excited to see how her style would mesh with the show’s established personalities. “Sandra is a pro,” wrote another fan. “She’ll bring a fresh energy to The Five.”
The big question now is how this change will affect the show’s dynamic. The Five has always thrived on the tension between its hosts, with debates often spilling over into heated arguments that reflect the political divisions in America. With Sandra Smith at the table, some wonder if the debates will be less combative, more analytical, or perhaps even more unpredictable. Smith’s reputation for fairness and directness could either smooth out some of the show’s rough edges or add a new layer of intensity.
Network insiders say the decision to bring in Smith was driven by a desire to shake things up and keep The Five at the top of the ratings. Fox News has faced increased competition from rival networks and digital platforms, and freshening up its flagship show is seen as a way to maintain its dominance. “We’re always looking for ways to innovate and give our viewers the best possible experience,” said one Fox executive. “Sandra brings a unique perspective and a wealth of experience. We’re excited to see where this goes.”
Meanwhile, the future for Jessica Tarlov remains uncertain. Some speculate she may be headed for a new role within the network, while others wonder if she’ll make the jump to another outlet. Whatever happens, her impact on The Five—and its audience—won’t be forgotten.
As the dust settles, one thing is clear: Fox News isn’t afraid to make bold moves. The pairing of Sandra Smith and Greg Gutfeld could usher in a brand-new era of fiery debates, unstoppable ratings, and a transformed dynamic for The Five. Whether viewers embrace the change or long for the old lineup, the network’s willingness to take risks is keeping everyone on the edge of their seats. The only question now is: what’s next?